Palliative Care: What It Is, What Research Shows, and Why It Remains Underused
May 27, 2022
· 3 min read
Palliative care is specialized medical care focused on providing relief from the symptoms, pain, and stress of serious illness. Its goal is to improve quality of life for both patients and families, and it is provided by a team including doctors, nurses, and other specialists who work alongside a patient's primary medical team rather than replacing it. Despite strong and growing evidence for its effectiveness and its alignment with what most patients say they want in terms of care that preserves dignity and comfort, palliative care remains dramatically underutilized across the American healthcare system.
The evidence base for palliative care has grown substantially. A landmark 2010 study published in the New England Journal of Medicine found that patients with metastatic lung cancer who received early palliative care alongside standard oncologic care had better quality of life, less depression, fewer aggressive end-of-life interventions, and actually lived longer than those who received standard care alone. The finding that palliative care extended life expectancy, which contradicted the widely held assumption that focusing on comfort care means giving up on treatment, had significant impact on medical culture and policy.
Subsequent research has replicated and extended these findings across other serious illnesses. Studies of early palliative care integration in heart failure, COPD, and other conditions find improvements in symptom management, reduced hospitalization, better patient and caregiver satisfaction, and in some cases reduced costs. The evidence is now strong enough that leading medical professional societies recommend early integration of palliative care for patients with serious illness, not only as a resource for the final days of life.
The persistent confusion between palliative care and hospice care contributes to underutilization. Hospice is a specific program of palliative care for people with terminal illness who are expected to live six months or less and who choose to focus on comfort rather than curative treatment. Palliative care is much broader, appropriate from the point of diagnosis of any serious illness regardless of prognosis, and can be provided alongside treatment. Research documents that many patients, families, and even healthcare providers do not clearly understand this distinction and that confusion contributes to late or no referral to palliative care.
Prognostic uncertainty and clinician discomfort with end-of-life conversations are significant barriers to palliative care referral. Many physicians find it difficult to have conversations about prognosis, goals of care, and patient values, either because they have not received training in these conversations or because they are reluctant to have discussions that might reduce patient hope. Research on end-of-life communication training programs for clinicians finds improvements in communication skills and in the quality of goals-of-care conversations, and several programs have demonstrated effects on care quality and costs.
Advance care planning, the process of identifying and documenting patient values, goals, and preferences for care in the event of serious illness or incapacity, is closely connected to palliative care but distinct from it. Research on advance care planning consistently documents that patients who have documented their preferences receive care more consistent with those preferences, experience less unwanted aggressive intervention, and have better quality of life at end of life. Yet advance care planning completion rates remain low in the general population.
Rural access to palliative care is particularly limited. Palliative care programs are concentrated in urban hospitals and academic medical centers, leaving rural communities with limited access to specialized palliative care expertise. Telepalliative care, which uses telehealth to provide palliative care consultation to patients and providers in rural and underserved settings, has shown feasibility and positive outcomes in research and represents a promising approach to extending palliative care access.
Pediatric palliative care addresses a distinct and often emotionally charged clinical context. Research on pediatric palliative care finds that it reduces symptom burden, improves family coping, and helps families make informed decisions about care for children with serious or life-threatening illnesses. Despite the evidence, pediatric palliative care services are even more limited in availability than adult services, and many children with serious illness never receive specialized palliative care consultation.
Most mental healthcare in the United States happens in primary care, not specialty settings. Research on integrated care models shows how to make this informal system work more effectively.
The United States faces a severe shortage of workers to care for its aging population. Research on the causes of the elder care workforce crisis and potential solutions is increasingly urgent.
Most Americans say they want to die at home, comfortably and with family present. Most die in hospitals and nursing facilities, often with unwanted interventions. The gap is addressable.